Carl Pope, Executive Director of the Sierra Club, reminds us not to be taken in by the predictable propaganda that emanates from the logging industry and their pawns in the Congress and the Bush Interior Department after every single major fire episode in the western U.S. (emphasis added)
[C]ommunities at South Lake Tahoe have been devastated by the Angora Wildland Fire which has scorched 2,500 acres and destroyed more than 200 buildings. The Tahoe basin's forests, overgrown from decades of well-intentioned fire suppression, need to be thinned of small trees and brush, particularly in the vicinity of homes in the urban-wildland interface. Climate change and beetle infestations have exacerbated the problem. While many good projects have gone forward, the problem is huge and much work remains to be done.
So, what has been the response of the timber industry's allies in Congress and in the media? Blame environmentalists. Senator Larry Craig announced that the problem was resistance in local communities to clearing out this brush. "We tried and weren't allowed to, and they lost their homes," Craig said. "I don't know if I want to smile, or I want to cry." The Lahontan Valley News claimed that the problem was the Sierra Club's opposition to logging on the national forests -- as if we had blocked timber sales in the back yards of Tahoe homeowners. Homeowners in one Tahoe subdivision claimed the problem was the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
The reality is simple -- and tragic. It costs money to clean brush, thin understory, remove downed wood and eliminate fire dangers around homes. Senator Craig has repeatedly rejected appeals by the Sierra Club to make such community protection zones the first priority for the Forest Service budget -- and the overwhelming bulk of the Forest Service funding still goes to subsidizing timber activities in the back country, far from homes, or fighting fires when it is too late. Very little goes to community protection, and the Forest Services continues to battle to cut down the remaining, fire-resistant, old-growth forests. As long as that continues to be true, there will be a fire next time. If we want to end these tragedies, we need to invest more in stopping them than we do in encouraging them. It's that simple, but the Ministry of Truth would like to tell us that spending our money miles from communities is the way to protect them.
The Lake Tahoe fire as well as the fires in Southern California in 2003 were predicted well in advance of their occurrence. Protestations that local citizens and environmentalists had no part in preventing forest restoration is plain obfuscation. Knowledgable people have been crying for action for years. Thinning at the margins (the wildland urban interface) will do nothing to save the forests. Most forest fires start in the backcountry. Yes it is a very good thing to prevent fires from destroying homes and businesses, but what's the point of living in a thinned forest island in the middle of a blackend landscape? You can do MUCH better than listen to Carl Pope. He has no respect for the forests or forest science. He is quite willing to let the forests burn so he can say he kept the loggers out. Well, thanks a H... of a lot Carl. I'm not a defender of the logging industry, but they are needed to implement the underfunded Healthy Forest Act and to save our forests. Forest Scientists estimate that over 50% of the forests in the West will burn within the next 25 years or less unless we take action.
The forests over much of the West are in a very unhealthy state for which the reasons are well known. The forests can be brought back to a sustainable condition through thinning and clearing as well as other remedial activities. The logging industry will have to play a major part in this where necessary. The forests around Lake Tahoe are some of the worst examples of unhealthy forests in the country. I suggest you go here: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/07/01/INGMVQNLIS1.DTL
to get a good understanding about how scientists feel.
Just remember. Restore it or it will burn, guaranteed.
Posted by: Le Messurier | July 01, 2007 at 12:21 PM